BAXTER, MN (trfnews.i234.me) — An Otsego man faces a felony theft charge involving an undelivered boat lift purchased by a Baxter couple.
Matthew Schiller Scheer, 52, is accused of taking $18,270.34 without delivering the promised equipment or refunding the money.
According to a Crow Wing County criminal complaint, the couple purchased a Floe boat lift through Scheer.
Investigators say bank records showed the payment was deposited and later spent without a documented boat lift purchase.
Couple Pays More Than $18,000 for Boat Lift
The Baxter Police Department began investigating the reported theft on June 29, 2026.
According to court records, a Baxter couple had agreed to purchase a new boat lift from Scheer.
Scheer was believed to own Brainerd Lakes Dock and Lifts, a business located in Nisswa.
The couple agreed to pay $18,270.34 for a Floe boat lift.
They mailed Scheer a check for the full amount, according to the complaint.
The agreement called for the new lift to be delivered and installed in spring 2026.
Scheer also arranged for Arrowwood Management to remove the couple’s old boat lift.
Boat Lift Never Delivered, Couple Says
During spring 2026, the couple repeatedly contacted Scheer about the missing equipment.
According to investigators, Scheer claimed the new boat lift had been ordered from Floe International.
He allegedly provided several explanations for why delivery had been delayed.
The couple eventually contacted Arrowwood Management about their old boat lift.
Arrowwood returned the original lift without charging them, according to the complaint.
Company representatives reportedly said they knew nothing about an order for a replacement lift.
They also stated that Scheer had asked them to sell the old equipment.
Manufacturer Reports Business Agreement Ended
On July 9, investigators contacted Floe International about the reported purchase.
A company representative reportedly said its agreement with Brainerd Lakes Dock and Lifts ended January 1, 2025.
That was months before the couple paid for their new boat lift.
Investigators also obtained copies of the couple’s check and related bank records.

Bank Records Raise Questions About Missing Money
According to the complaint, the couple’s check was dated September 30, 2025.
Investigators determined Scheer deposited the $18,270.34 check into a BMO bank account on October 16, 2025.
Records showed the account was opened that same day.
By July 17, 2026, the account reportedly contained only $392.33.
Investigators reported that much of the money was used for personal purchases and bills.
They found no account transactions showing a payment toward a new Floe boat lift.
The complaint also describes text messages exchanged between Scheer and the couple.
Those messages reportedly included delivery promises, explanations for delays, and an apology.
The couple demanded either the boat lift or a full refund.
According to the complaint, they had not received a refund.
Felony Theft-by-Swindle Charge Filed
Prosecutors charged Scheer with felony theft by swindle under Minnesota Statute 609.52.
The allegation involves obtaining more than $5,000 through alleged deception.
The charge carries a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison, a $20,000 fine, or both.
Investigators attempted to obtain a statement from Scheer on September 22.
A representative for Scheer reportedly said he would not provide a statement.
Crow Wing County Court Case
The case is filed in Minnesota’s Ninth Judicial District under court number 18-CR-26-3882.
The prosecutor’s file number is CR-2026-1300.
The supplied complaint does not establish a plea, conviction, or sentencing outcome.
The allegations remain unproven, and Scheer is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Readers can search public case information through Minnesota Court Records Online.
I’m Adrian Cole reporting for TRF News.
Copyright 2026 TRF News. All rights reserved.
Choose your hometown and the stories you care about.
Get My Town Alerts →Trending Stories
Greenbush Man Accused of Burning Girlfriend’s BelongingsNovember 13, 20263,640 views
Near Bemidji: Missing Corey Bryant’s Remains FoundNovember 14, 20261,962 views
Thief River Falls Cocaine Case Ends in 4-Year SentenceNovember 12, 20261,550 views
Multiple Fire Crews Battle Stephen Building Center FireNovember 13, 20261,144 views
Warroad Man Charged in Baudette Strangulation CaseNovember 16, 20261,030 views








